Hope for your financial life and beyond

Should I Ever Get Rental Car Insurance?

The first time I ever rented a car I was unprepared for a very specific question. The agent behind the counter asked “Would you like to purchase rental car insurance?”

“I don’t know,” I thought, standing there with the deer-in-the-headlights look. My only thought was getting behind the wheel of the convertible I’d reserved.

So I listened to the spiel and bought the rental car insurance. A few minutes later I’m top down and cruising around Saint Croix with my new bride.

rental car insuranceI realized later my decision had been a small financial mistake.

There is no question you need insurance to drive. According to the Department of Motor Vehicles, every state requires motorists to carry a minimum level of auto insurance coverage (or the equivalent in financial responsibility waivers). Such coverage is necessary to protect against damage to property or injuries to people caused by an accident.

But if you own a car, your rental car may already be covered. Once you realize the rules and what your own auto insurance policy covers, you will be able to answer the “Should I get rental car insurance” question with confidence.

To do so, you must prepare in advance by doing two things:

1) learn what types of coverage are offered by the rental car company and

2) make two important phone calls before you are standing at the counter.

Types of Rental Car Insurance Coverage

Rental car insurance is state regulated. The types of coverage and the cost will vary from state to state. In general though, these types of coverage are what you can expect to find:

1. Loss Damage Waiver (LDW)

This is also called Collision Damage Waiver (CDW). It is not technically an insurance product. Rather it “waives” the driver of financial responsibility if there is damage to the rental car or if it is stolen. If you refuse this product and aren’t covered by your own auto insurance policy, you assume responsibility for any damages to the car up to its full value.

It’s important to note that even with this waiver in place coverage can be retracted if damage to the rental car results from:

Do I Need This?

If you own a car, the comprehensive/collision portion of your personal vehicle insurance should cover damage to the rental car. However, collision is not required in any state. So consider purchasing LDW if you’ve dropped that coverage to save money on your personal car insurance policy.

2. Liability Insurance

Liability insurance provides coverage for medical expenses and damage to another person’s property if you caused the accident.

According to the Insurance Information Institute (III), the law requires car rental companies to provide the state required minimum levels of liability coverage. It’s a cost of running their business. However, the level of coverage they provide is low (based on the state minimums) and does not offer you much protection in case of a serious accident.

Do I Need This?

The law requires liability insurance. Therefore, the policy on the car you drive includes it. Review the policy or call your insurance agent to determine if the level of liability coverage is sufficient. If you don’t have a car then consider purchasing the additional coverage from the rental car company.

3. Personal Accident Insurance

This insurance covers the driver’s and passenger’s medical bills resulting from an accident.

Do I Need This?

If you have health insurance or auto insurance, you should be covered already. The portion of your insurance that covers you is referred to as personal injury protection (PIP)

(PIP is not part of comprehensive or collision. It is a separate portion of an auto insurance policy that covers injuries to the driver and passengers of your – the policyholder’s – car.)

4. Personal Effects Coverage

Personal effects coverage protects your belongings from theft. If items are stolen out of the rental car you can be reimbursed for those items.

Do I Need This?

Most homeowners or renters insurance policies cover theft of personal items that occur away from your primary residence.

Ask Questions Beforehand

You can see the common theme on whether to purchase these rental car insurances rests with your own personal insurance policies.

So it would be a wise move to review the coverage you already have in place before renting a car. If necessary, call and speak with your insurance agent to clarify any gray areas. Ask them specific questions about what your auto, home and health insurance covers in case you have an accident with a rental car.

A second phone call to make would be to your credit card company. Many credit card companies provide collision and theft protection if you use their card to rent the car. These benefits usually kick in after your other insurances have been exhausted.

(However, if you don’t have the other personal insurances then you shouldn’t count on your credit card to pay. You should purchase the coverage offered by the rental car company.)

So do a little planning in advance of signing that rental car contract and learn what personal coverage you already have in place. It may help you save money by not purchasing a product you don’t really need.

If you would like to read further about rental car insurance, check out this great resource at LendEdu.com.

Questions: Have you ever/do you ever purchase rental car insurance? If so, what was the reasoning for your purchase? What is your favorite type of car to rent?

Image by Atomic Taco at Flickr Creative Commons

I hope you enjoyed that post. Want more?
Sign up to receive my blog posts via email and get your free gift...
99 Ways to Spend Less and Save More

Privacy Guarantee: I will not share your email with anyone.


  1. Ok, so I had to come back and re-read your blog and emailed my agent twice. We have been renting a car on trips recently and I am noticing the increase in costs since we are renting for several days and it adds up since you are charged per day for the insurance, as well as the car. My agent confirmed that with full-coverage on our vehicles we are covered and DO NOT need to purchase ANY of the additional insurance options at the counter. ~ Thank you

  2. Jayson @ Monster Piggy Bank says

    My personal insurance has collision coverage such as damage to my own car resulting from an accident with another vehicle and/or comprehensive such as damage to my car caused by fire, theft, vandalism, etc.?

  3. This is a good topic because so many people accept the insurance, without really thinking about it. I think I was the same as you, I accepted it the first time because I had no clue. Once I learned more about it, I have waived it ever since.

    One thing that did crack me up is that my husband got pulled over in a rental car (I can’t remember why, it might have been a check point or something). His insurance information did not match the registration of course. The officer just could. not. understand this. He did eventually give him a pass.

Speak Your Mind